Link to RCS
 
 
  Daily news and commentary on the key issues involving radio and the Internet Link to previous issue Link to next issue   
     


Welcome!
Contact RAIN
Feedback form

Hanson Consulting














Proposed
  recordkeeping
  requirements
CARP recommends
   flat-rate royalty
CARP based rate
  on Yahoo! deal
"Day of Silence"
   is on!
20 House members
   write Librarian
Media coverage of
   "Day of Silence"
Copyright Office
  roundtable
House Judiciary
   subcommittee
   hearing
"RIAA may win
  battle but..."
CARP rejected!
Royalty rates
  around world
"Likely" record-
   keeping rules
Senate hearing on
   CARP process
Librarian's decision:
  $.0007/perf.
Congressmen
  weigh response
Mark Cuban's
  e-mail to RAIN
KH analysis of
  Cuban e-mail
Yahoo halts
  Broadcast.com
  streams
VOW petitions
  Congress
Million Fax March
Labels to Net Radio:
  Die now
NAB legal appeal
KPIG drops streaming
Small webcasters
  benefit concert
Internet Radio
  Fairness Act
Artemis Records to
  allow free streaming
Webcasters, labels
  appeal LOC ruling

Librarian wants to
  block some appeals

Moby speaks out
RIAA, small web-
  casters talking
"Webcasters, labels
  need to compromise"
Royalty Voodoo
  Economics Pt. 1
BRS study shows US
  'casters leaving Net
B'casters move to
  "stay" fees
Inslee calls CARP
  "terrible legislation"
Small 'casters return
  to Capitol Hill
"Compromise will pay
  off for everyone"
Simson says talks
  are progressing
H.R. 5469
"Call your
  Congressman"
Conyers speaks out
  against H.R. 5469
H.R. 5469 pulled,
  deal may be near
Artists willing to kill
  webcasting for $0?
Details of possible deal
Will broadcasters
  block the deal?
An agreement reached
"Webcaster royalty is
  technological
  fetishism"
Artist/label dispute
  threatens
  compromise
H.R. 5469 passes
  House!
New deal doesn't help
  college stations
RAIN's summary
   of H.R. 5469
Benefits, options of
  H.R. 5469
How to save the bill
VOW letter to Senate
Copyright Office
  denies b'casters'
  stay motion
"RIAA motivation and
  the impact of SWAA"
SWAA pros & cons
SWAA dies in Senate
RAIN proposes post-
  SWAA action
Live365 stay motion
  denied
SoundExchange offers
  "minimum fee" plan
Live365 files
  emergency stay
Net radio copyright
  basics pt. 1
Net radio copyright
  basics pt. 2
Tentative agreement
  on 5469
Congress passes
  SWSA
RAIN answers
  SWSA questions
President signs
  SWSA into law


Past issues
Site reviews
Guest essays
Metrics analysis

Copyright Law
DMCA



Arbitron's Measurecast
Ratings:
Weekly:
Week of Mar. 3
Week of Feb. 24
Week of Feb. 17
Week of Feb. 10

Monthly:
February 2003
January 2003
December 2002

Click here to make RAIN your default homepage!


We'll send you a brief daily summary of each day's stories with a clickable link to the RAIN home page.

 

 

Due to coverage of yesterday's late-breaking news of the RIAA/DiMA webcasting royalties proposal, we've postponed Part 5 of Kurt's "The Future of Radio" series until Monday's issue. If you'd like to go back to previous installments of the series, simply click the following links: Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4.

Headline: Aside from avoiding CARP, new deal does little fro webcasters
BY PAUL MALONEY
The biggest news about yesterday's late-announced webcasting royalty agreement between the RIAA and DiMA (see yesterday afternoon's RAIN News Flash here) isLink: RIAA that it's really no significant change from the 1999-2002 Librarian of Congress's rate.

The agreement, however, does save both sides a costly arbitration to settle the rate at which webcasters would pay royalties to the owners of sound recording copyrights for the use of their music. .

Late yesterday DiMA, a lobbying group that represents mostly large webcasters and technology companies, announced that it had Link: DiMAreached an agreement with the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) on a webcasting royalty rate for 2003 and 2004. The joint proposal was submitted to the Copyright Office, which presumably will publish the deal for review and comment, then decide whether to approve it for industry-wide use.

Under the deal, "nonsubscription" webcasters would have the choice of paying 0.0762 cents per listener per song (actually slightly higher than the Librarian's determination), or 1.17 cents per listener per hour (which means this rateLink: SoundExchange would be advantageous to the webcaster if the channel averages more than 15.35 songs per hour). Minimum fees for nonsubscription webcasts leap to $2,500 per year (from $500 per year for 1998-2002).

Smaller webcasters — those with revenues of less than $500,000 in 2003 — will continue to be able to elect, if they prefer, the rate set in the Small Webcaster Settlement Agreement — 10% of the webcaster's first $250K in gross income and 12% of any additional income (or 7% of expenses, whichever is higher).

"First, webcasters remain at a Photo: Jonathan Pottercompetitive disadvantage to terrestrial radio by having to pay huge royalties for sound recordings that broadcasters get for free," acknowledged Jonathan Potter (pictured below right), executive director of the Digital Media Association (DiMA). "And second, the arbitration process that determines these royalties is sorely in need of reform."

Absent a joint industry proposal to the US Copyright Office, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) mandates that the Copyright Office convene an arbitration panel to recommend a royalty rate to the Library of Congress. This arbitration, known as the Copyright Arbitration royalty panel (CARP) wasset to begin May 5.

The executive director of SoundExchange, the record industry body set up to collect and distribute the royalties, agreed that avoiding arbitration was a benefit, and added that the proposal would prevent webcasters from "holding out" on the money they owe.

"Webcasters had stopped paying royalties pending the setting of new rates even though they continue to exploit sound recordingsLink: U.S. Copyright Office for their businesses," said John Simson (pictured below left) in a press release. "This action threatened to deprive SoundExchange of royalties necessary to continue operations, and the Register of Copyrights has even asked Congress to clarify that webcasters cannot do this in the future."

Note that this deal includes terms for new subscription-based models, which can pay the same rates as nonsubscription webcasters,Photo: John Simson or instead can pay 10.9% of the subscription revenues, (but at least 27 cents per month per subscriber), with a $5,000 per year minimum for webcasters electing the "percentage-of-subscription-revenue" rate.

Also note that webcasts of AM/FM broadcasters and those of noncommercial/nonprofit entities are not eligible for this deal. Also excluded would be small webcasters who have elected to pay royalties under the Small Webcaster Settlement Act of 2002, or SWSA.

Some webcasters complained that the new proposal does nothing to help the upstart businesses in the industry. According to DiMA's press release, bigger media companies like RealNetworks, Yahoo!, America Online, Microsoft, MusicMatch, Listen.com, and FullAudio support the deal.

Even Potter admitted that this proposal's main benefit would be to keep the royalty determination out of arbitration. "The agreement is a temporary band-aid that avoids millions of dollars of legal fees associated with a broken arbitration process," he said in yesterday's press release.

DiMA and RIAA Joint Royalty Proposal
License Fees:  
Eligible Nonsubscription Transmission Services

Option of paying royalties as follows:

  • Per Performance Option - 0.0762 cents ($0.000762) per performance, except that 4% of performances shall bear no royalty.
  • Aggregate Tuning Hour Option - 1.17 cents ($0.0117) per aggregate tuning hour.
New Subscription Services

Option of paying royalties as follows:

  • Per Performance Option - 0.0762 cents ($0.000762) per performance, except that 4% of performances shall bear no royalty.
  • Aggregate Tuning Hour Option - 1.17 cents ($0.0117) per aggregate tuning hour.
  • Percentage of Subscription Revenues Option - 10.9% of "Subscription Service Revenues," but in no event less than 27 cents per month for each person who subscribes to the subscription service or to whom service is delivered without a fee (e.g., during a trial period).
Minimum Fees:  
Nonsubscription Services $2,500 per year
Subscription Services
  • Per Performance Option & Aggregate Tuning Hours Option - $2,500 per year.
  • Percentage of Subscription Revenues Option - $5,000 per year.

RAIN Reader Cocktail Party at NAB: Tuesday 4/8 at 4:30pm at Gordon Biersch
If you're planning to attend NAB 2003 in Las Vegas (April 5-10; details here), we hope you'll join us for our RAIN reader get-togther. We've reserved the patio of the Gordon Biersch Brewery Restaurant (about a $4 cab ride from the Convention Center) on Tuesday, April 8th.

This year, we've also reserved
a private room for the U.S. debut of Kurt's "The Future of Radio" speech for those who'd like an advance look at it. (Please note we've moved the time up a bit. The presentation will now be at 4:30pm, and cocktails at 5:00pm.) See you there!
The RAIN Reader Cocktail Party at NAB 2003 is co-sponsored by Limelight Networks, RadioWebStuff, StreamGuys, InvisibleHand Networks, Ramp^Rate, and RCS. Make plans to meet representatives of those firms at the event!
 
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
 

Headline: Audience size surges for online news radio's war coverage
BY PAUL MALONEY
Coverage of the US/Iraqi conflict is driving increased media use among consumers, and that includes news and talk available via Internet radio.

ABC Radio's WLS-AM/Chicago and Clear Channel KFI-AM/Los Angeles both reached the top ten most-listened-to Net radio channels according to Arbitron's Measurecast ratings for the week of March 17. WLS-AM hit number three with 255,623 hours TTSL (or Total Time Spent Listening). KFI-AM ranked tenth with a 130,233 TTSL.

And, according to their content delivery service provider Speedera, National Public Radio (NPR) saw a record 8-fold increase in audio usage on the first day of the war. NPR's site offers original online content and audio streaming, hourly newscasts, and seven years of archived audio and information. NPR's online listenership is not rated by Arbitron.

"With the beginning of the war, we have seen a significant increase in online tuning to news and talk Internet radio stations," said Bill Rose (pictured below right), vice president and general manager, Arbitron Internet Broadcast Services, in a press release. "For the week of March 17, the 65 Talk and News/Talk stations measured by Arbitron MeasureCast Ratings had a combined 1,389,717 hours of TTSL, nearly three times the listenership of the same stations for the week of January 27, which had 493,430 hours of TTSL."

In September of last year, KFI ranked #48 in Measurecast's monthly rankings (at the time a separate competitor of Arbitron's, here) with just 125,896 TTSL for the month, while WLS was not rated in the top 50. In fact, Cox News/Talk WSB-AM/Atlanta was the highest-rated News Talk station at #26, with 182,995 TTSL for the month. Arbitron's monthly ratings for that period (here) have Bonneville news station WTOP-AM/Washington D.C. at #18 (193,700 TTSL, again, a monthly total), the highest news or news/talk outlet of all rated stations.

One year prior to that, for the month that included the September 11th terrorist attacks in New York and Washington, WLS was ranked #27 (64,816 TTSL), while KFI did not appear in those ratings (here, though WSB-AM was #8 with 137,250 TTSL, and Salem KRLA-AM/Los Angeles was #16 with 95,525 TTSL). Boston University's WBUR ranked #4 in Arbitron's list (here), but with only 187,400 for the entire month.

The Future of Radio The US debut of Kurt's "The Future of Radio" speech (in a slightly-condensed preview version) will take place next week in Las Vegas, immediately preceding the RAIN Reader Cocktail Party at Gordon Biersch Brewery Restaurant (Tuesday, April 7th, at the new time: 4:30 PM). To reserve a seat for the presentation, call 1-312-527-3879 or write kurt@kurthanson.com.
 


Have an opinion? Drop us a note! (Or, to use your own e-mail software, click here.)

  Your e-mail address:
  Your name (if not obvious from your e-mail address):
    Kurt and Paul, this is deep background -- don't quote me!

        Thanks!

 
 

We'll send you a brief daily summary of each day's stories with a clickable link to the RAIN home page.
Reader Feedback
Here's feedback on yesterday's news of a joint RIAA/DiMA proposal (here, and in today's issue)...

"Based on what bit-rate the webcaster streams..."


That deal sounds good however, the rates still seem a bit higher than what many webcasters are able to afford.

I think what really needs to be done, if someone hasn't suggested this already, is instead design a royalty plan that is based on what bit-rate the webcaster (no matter if it's Net-Only, AM/FM simulcasts, non-commercial broadcasts, etc.) streams rather than the current CARP rates.

Webcasters that are streaming a bitrate of 32K or lower quality, since the low quality sound is least desirable for CD burning, should only have to pay very little in royalties, while the webcasters that are streaming a bitrate higher than 32k should have to pay more royalties.

Basically, the higher the bitrate, higher the royalty obligation.

  Bill



This is in regards to the announced AOL Broadband/Infinity Radio partnership (in RAIN here)...

"Infinity should have looked at subscription models like Real..."


Kurt:

I feel that it will be a complete failure because of AOL's previous track record.

AOL's market share is declining because most educated Internet users can easily find information online without having to go through simplified, yet cluttered menus. The new Broadband service won't reverse AOL's current woes, even with the availability of exclusive content such as Infinity radio stations. Infinity should have looked at an independent subscription model similar to RealNetworks' RadioPass if they want to enter the streaming radio arena. Many devout listeners would be willing to pay a monthly fee in order to receive KROQ or WFAN on their computers.

Despite Infinity's tiny step in the right direction, I believe Howard Stern's show will NOT be streamed by any of its stations in the years to come.

  Deep background only
 
Link: Hanson Consulting
 
Upcoming conferences
April 5-10 NAB 2003: Las Vegas
April 13-15 Public Broadcasting Internet Conference: Minneapolis
May 7-9 Interactive Media Conference & Trade Show: San Diego
June 19-21 The R&R 2003 Convention: Beverly Hills
July 7-9 The Radio Festival 2003: Birmingham, UK
August 6-9 The R&R Triple-A Summit: Boulder
October 1-3 The NAB Radio Show: Philadelphia
October 19-21 NAB European Radio Conference: London
October 22-25 CMJ Music Marathon: New York

Search RAIN

(Hint: Use quotes)
Advanced Search

Click Here for AccuRadio

Vendor Guide Ver. 3.0

Link: AccuPortal

Publications
R&R
RBR
Radio Ink
All Access
Inside Radio
   

Internet Pubs.
Red Herring
Business 2.0
   
Other Publications
(was eRadio)
(Taz Media)
FMQB
   

Software for RAIN's daily e-mail reminders provided by:

 


 
 

TOP

Copyright 2003, RAIN Publications, Inc. All rights reserved.
All logos and trademarks are property of their respective owners.

Your RAIN staff
Kurt Hanson
Publisher
Paul Maloney
Editor
Ralph Sledge
"Site of the Day" Editor
David Don
Developer
Brad Knutson
Intern
Ben Huh
Project Manager